Foul Play

Original Until Dawn was released in 2015. Since then, fans have repeatedly asked developers to continue the horror. However, executive director and producer of Supermassive studio Pete Samuels, in an interview with GameInformer, explained why the sequel never saw the light of day.

After the release of Until Dawn, many began to ask for a sequel. This is still happening, so we know that the sequel has its own fan base. However, creating an anthology will allow us to satisfy not only the desire of fans from our point of view, but also our own desire to do what we love, that is, to create new stories and characters, and also to do it more often than once or twice in several years.
                                                                                                                                                                                            Pete Samuels

According to the developers, the Dark Pictures anthology will allow them to start from scratch and give them creative freedom. Within its framework, five different games will be released, which will focus on different sub-genres of horror.

If we were engaged in a sequel, we would not know who survived. We could probably find out from your save, but we do not want to create a sequel to this. We want to create a new story with new characters.
                                                                                                                                                       Dan MacDonald, Producer